U.S. Retail sales unexpectedly declined in Apr for the second time in 3 months, burdened with soft sales of cars and building materials and indicating consumer spending will remain subdued this quarter. The value of overall sales dropped 0.2% following a 1.7% increase the previous month which has been the strongest increase since 2017, according to Commerce Department figures released Wednesday. In comparison with a median forecast in Bloomberg’s poll calling for a 0.2% rise. Sales from the control team, subset, which many analysts see as a clearer measure of underlying consumer demand, were unchanged from the previous months, below projections for a 0.3percent gain.

The measure excludes food providers, car dealers, building materials stores and gasoline stations. The figures, also reflecting weakness in the group which includes online revenue, suggest spending remains soft following the weakest increase in a year. That could bolster pressure from President Donald Trump and markets to cut borrowing costs involving unexpectedly low inflation, though Federal Reserv espolicy makers have promised patience, as steady job and income gains should encourage purchases in months. The retail record followed another round of downbeat data from the Fed showing U.S. Factory production fell in Apr for a 3rd time in four months with a wide decrease led by weakness in machines and motor vehicles.

The cooler readings on the world economics followed reports that investment, retail sales and industrial output slowed more than economists forecast in Apr, underscoring challenges to global growth from Trump trade war. The U.S. Retail statistics are a bit of a downer for the long term economic outlook, but don’t move the huge picture needle much, Stephen Stanley, chief economist at Amherst Pierpont Securities, said in a note. Recent seesaw patterns indicate there might be a strong bounceback in May. Merchants can be poised to take a further hit if Trump follow through on his threat to impose tariffs of 25% on nearly all staying Chinese imports, which would probably force Americans to soak up higher costs.

Unlike the previous objectives of U.S. Levies, the vast majority of this tranche is consumer goods. The report showed seven out of the 13 leading retail classes decreased, with some other down sectors including clothing, health and personal care, and electronics and appliances. Categories with gains included general goods, food and beverage stores, and restaurants and bars. Earnings at car dealers fell 1.1%, the most since January, after increasing 3.2percent in the previous month. Industry data from the Wards Automotive group formerly showed unit sales located touching the lowest level since 2017. Filling station receipts increased 1.8%, the report showed, as petroleum prices rallied. The amounts are not adjusted for price change, so higher retail sales in the class could reflect increased gasoline costs, earnings, or both. Excluding cars and gasoline, retail sales fell 0.2% following a 1.1percent increase.